A bright, staged living room in a Windermere home
Home value · Windermere, FL

What's your Windermere home worth? From a value range to the equity you move with

Start with an instant online estimate, then get Andy's free market analysis: recent sales, the homes you'd compete with and your home's own features, emailed to you the same day.

Jan 1Appraiser's value dateFlorida Statutes 192.042
2.7%2026 homestead capSave Our Homes, F.S. 193.155
3+Closed comparablesFannie Mae appraisal rules
$500KPortable tax savingsFlorida Statutes 193.155(8)
Free home valuation · three short steps

Get your free valuation.

Enter your address for an instant estimate. Andy then reviews recent sales, the homes yours would compete with and your home's own features, and emails you a value range the same day. It's free, with no obligation, whether you plan to sell now or later.

Lofty's valuation form appears here. Prefer to call? (407) 619-3517

An instant figure is an automated estimate: a starting point, not Andy's opinion of value. Prefer to talk it through? Call (407) 619-3517 · Andy Neal, Realtor · The Agency FL

Your valuation at a glance

Looks at
Recent sales, active competition and your home's features: lake or golf frontage, gate, lot, condition and finish
You get
An instant online estimate, then Andy's value range from comparable sales
Format
By email
Timing
The same day
Cost
Free, no obligation
Who for
Any owner, in any area and at any price
Comparative market analysis
Florida Statutes 475.612(3)

A real estate broker or sales associate may give a comparative market analysis or price opinion in the ordinary course of business, but it may not be referred to or construed as an appraisal.

Andy's valuation is this kind of opinion. A lender's appraisal comes from a state-certified or licensed appraiser.

Why equity, not just value

From price to what you move with.

Your next move depends on equity: a realistic price, less the costs of selling and the mortgage. If you're moving to another Florida home, your Save Our Homes savings can come with you.

Florida sets some of these costs by law, so they can be worked out before you list. The others depend on your contract and your loan. See every line on the seller costs table.

Illustration on a $1,500,000 sale. Deed stamps $0.70 per $100 (F.S. 201.02); owner's title at the promulgated rate (Rule 69O-186.003), if the contract has the seller pay; HOA estoppel cap as adjusted by DBPR in 2022 (F.S. 720.30851); portability F.S. 193.155(8).

  1. Value rangeComparable sales, competing homes, lake, lot and condition
    $1,500,000
  2. Deed stampsFlorida documentary stamp tax on the deed
    −$10,500
  3. Owner's title policyIf the contract has the seller pay
    −$6,325
  4. HOA estoppel certificateCapped by law; more for a rush
    Up to $299
  5. Commission and taxesThe commission you agree; your share of the year's taxes
    Your figures
  6. Mortgage payoffFrom your lender's payoff letter
    Your figure
  7. Equity to move withPlus up to $500,000 of portable Save Our Homes savings
    Your range
Online estimate, CMA or appraisal

Three numbers, three jobs.

Each answers a different question. Only a licensed appraiser can give an appraisal; an agent gives a market analysis; software gives an estimate.

Online estimate, agent's comparative market analysis and appraisal compared
Compare Online estimateAutomated valuation model Agent's CMAIncluding Andy's free valuation AppraisalBy a licensed appraiser
Who makes it Software A licensed real estate agent A state-certified or licensed appraiserF.S. 475.611
What it uses Public records and recent sales Closed, pending and active homes, and the home itself At least 3 closed comparables, normally from the last 12 monthsFannie Mae B4-1.3-08
What it misses Interior upgrades, the view, dock permits, a home's place on the course It's an opinion, not a formal valuation Listings and pending sales count only as support
Legal name An estimate A comparative market analysis or price opinion; may not be called an appraisalF.S. 475.612(3) An appraisalF.S. 475.611
Use it for A quick starting point Setting a price and planning a move A lender's mortgage decision

Florida Statutes 475.611 and 475.612 (2026); Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08, comparable sales (June 4, 2025). Lenders that use automated valuation models must meet federal quality-control standards from October 1, 2025 (89 FR 64538); that rule doesn't cover estimates on consumer websites.

Your TRIM notice, decoded

Why the Appraiser's value isn't a price.

The Orange County Property Appraiser values every parcel for tax, as of January 1. Three numbers follow from that, and none of them is what a buyer would pay today.

  1. Just valueThe Appraiser's market value as of January 1, by mass appraisal.F.S. 192.042, 193.011
  2. Assessed valueJust value after the caps: for a homestead, up 3% or CPI a year at most.F.S. 193.155
  3. Taxable valueAssessed value less exemptions, such as the homestead exemption.F.S. 196.031

Why just value differs from a sale price

  • It's a January 1 snapshotThe market can move by the time you sell · F.S. 192.042
  • The law deducts the costs of a saleThe "usual and reasonable fees and costs of the sale" · F.S. 193.011(8)
  • Unfinished work doesn't countImprovements not substantially complete on January 1 get no value
  • It's a mass appraisalBuilt from recorded sales and records for every parcel, not a visit to yours

The Save Our Homes cap, by year

Cap on homestead assessment increases, 2026
2.7%
2025 2.9% · 2024: 3.0% (CPI was 3.4%)

When a home sells, the buyer's assessment resets to just value, so the buyer's tax bill can be higher than yours. Sellers must say so in the property tax disclosure summary.F.S. 689.261

ApprovedNov 32026

Amendment 3 passed with about 62% of the vote. From 2027 the non-school homestead exemption rises to $150,000, then $250,000 in 2028, and the non-homestead cap drops from 10% to 5% (non-school). It changes taxable value, not market value.Florida Division of Elections, Ballot No. 3; approved November 3, 2026

Approved

Florida Statutes 192.042, 193.011, 193.155, 196.031 and 689.261 (2026). Cap by year: Seminole County Property Appraiser, Save Our Homes page (the cap is set statewide). "Mass appraisal" describes how property appraisers value every parcel each year; it isn't an Orange County statement.

Lake, gate, lot and roof

What moves value in Windermere.

Lake, gate, lot and roof can each move a price more than size alone. These are the factors Andy weighs, with a source for each.

Andy Neal, Realtor, The Agency FL
I start with comparable sales, but Windermere homes can't always be valued accurately by simply comparing price per square foot. Two properties of similar size can be very different depending on their community, lot, condition, upgrades, privacy, age, water frontage, golf frontage and overall setting.
· REALTOR®, The Agency FL · #1 in Windermere, RealTrends Verified 2025 · FL Lic. SL3396613

On the water

  • Which lake, and whether it's on the Butler ChainSome nearby lakes aren't connected to the chain
  • Lake size and water qualityAn Orange County study of 54,000 sales found both matter, more so near the water (data 1996 to 2004)
  • A permitted dockOrange County EPD permits docks; a new dock application is $965.50 from October 1, 2026
  • Seawall and shoreline permitsSeawall work needs a public hearing and county commission approval
  • The flood zoneAppraisers must consider the FEMA flood zone

On land

  • Community, gate and golfIn Andy's experience, amenities, a guard gate and golf change which homes buyers compare
  • Lot, view and privacyPosition within the community, not only size
  • Size, age and conditionStatutory factors in every just value · F.S. 193.011
  • Roof age and insurabilityCitizens asks for 5+ years of roof life on older roofs, and a 4-point on homes over 20 years old
  • Town of Windermere or countyDifferent tax rates change the cost of owning, not the price itself

Andy's words: his downsizing guide (October 2026). Walsh, Milon and Scrogin, Land Economics 87(4), 2011; Orange County EPD dock and shoreline permit pages (read October 22, 2026); Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08; Citizens Property Insurance inspections page; F.S. 193.011. Lakes and taxes in detail: the Windermere, FL guide, lakefront homes on the Butler Chain and Windermere's gated communities.

Public records · a few minutes

Check your own records.

Before you talk numbers with anyone, look at what the public record says about your home. It's also what a buyer's agent will look at.

When you request your valuation, tell Andy about anything that isn't on the record: recent upgrades, a new roof, dock or seawall permits.

  1. Look up your parcel

    Search your address or owner name on the Orange County Property Appraiser's site for values, sale history and exemptions.

    ocpafl.org
  2. Read your TRIM notice

    Mailed each August: just, assessed and taxable value, the proposed taxes, and any portability on your record.

    OCPA Portability FAQ
  3. Disagree with the value?

    You can petition the Value Adjustment Board within 25 days of the TRIM mailing.

    F.S. 194.011; Orange County Value Adjustment Board
  4. Check recorded documents

    Deeds, mortgages and liens are in the Orange County Comptroller's Official Records.

    Orange County Comptroller
  5. Check permit history

    Orange County Fast Track lists permits; homes in the Town of Windermere are permitted through the Town.

    Fast Track; Town of Windermere FAQ
Portability · moving to another Florida home

Take your tax savings with you.

Save Our Homes portability moves up to $500,000 of the gap between your just and assessed value to a new Florida homestead. Here are the Property Appraiser's own worked examples.

Moving up

$100,000
savings carried to the new home
Old home
$300,000 just value, $200,000 assessed
New home
$500,000 just value, assessed at $400,000
Taxable
$375,000 after a $25,000 exemption

Downsizing

$90,000
the same 60% share, on a smaller price
Old home
$500,000 just value, $200,000 assessed: 60% savings
New home
$150,000 just value, assessed at $60,000
Rule
Downsizing keeps the same percentage of savings, up to $500,000
  • File form DR-501T with the new homestead application by March 1You must have had a homestead exemption on January 1 of one of the 3 prior years
  • It's based on the Appraiser's certified value, not your sale priceOCPA Portability FAQ
  • Up to $250,000 of gain on a main home is free of federal tax ($500,000 for a married couple filing jointly)Owned and lived in for 2 of the last 5 years · IRS Topic 701

Orange County Property Appraiser, Portability FAQ (Rev. 08/2021); F.S. 193.155(8); IRS Topic 701 (October 12, 2026). Planning the sale and the next purchase: selling and downsizing in the right order and Andy's downsizing guide.

Measured by someone else

A realistic number, from the start.

#1 in WindermereBy volume and by sides, 2025RealTrends Verified, 2025 sales data
170Five-star Google reviewsGoogle Business Profile, October 2026
$150M+Sold in Florida since 2017Andy Neal, November 2026
We initially had a US realtor who advised us our home was worth much much lower than its actual value. … Andy immediately advised the first realtor's value was too low and we listed with him at a much higher price and the home sold within 2 days.
Clare O. · Seller based in the UK · Google review
Andy was informative about prices and always extremely attentive answering my questions straight away.
Julie R. · Google review

Reviews quoted from Google, as shown on Andy's reviews page (October 2026). Neither review describes the valuation service itself.

After the number

Where to go from here.

Sellers

Sell your Windermere home

How Andy prices, prepares and markets a home, with Florida's selling costs line by line.

How Andy sells
About Andy

A luxury agent in Windermere

His background, his results and how he works with sellers and buyers.

Meet Andy
The area

The Windermere, FL guide

The Town and the 34786 address, the Butler Chain, tax rates and flood checks.

Read the guide
Answers open on the page

Home value in Windermere, answered.

01How do I find out what my Windermere home is worth?

Start with three numbers: an online estimate, the Orange County Property Appraiser's just value (as of January 1) and an agent's comparative market analysis based on recent comparable sales. Only a licensed appraiser can give an appraisal. For a lake or golf home, a review of truly comparable sales matters most.

02What's the difference between a CMA and an appraisal?

A CMA is a real estate agent's opinion of price from comparable sales and current competition, and Florida law says it may not be called an appraisal. An appraisal is done by a state-certified or licensed appraiser, usually for a lender, using at least three closed comparables, normally from the last 12 months.

03Is Andy Neal's home valuation free?

Yes, with no obligation, for any owner. Enter your address for an instant online estimate, and Andy emails you a value range the same day, from recent sales, active competition and your home's features. It's an agent's comparative market analysis, not an appraisal. Use the form on this page or call (407) 619-3517.

04Why is my Property Appraiser "just value" different from what my home would sell for?

Just value is set as of January 1, not today. By law it allows for the usual costs of a sale and leaves out improvements unfinished on January 1, and it comes from a mass appraisal of every parcel. Your assessed value can be lower still because of the Save Our Homes cap.

05How much can my homestead assessment go up each year in Florida?

By the lower of 3% or the change in the Consumer Price Index. For 2026 the cap is 2.7% (2.9% in 2025). When the home sells, the new owner's assessment resets to just value, so the buyer's tax bill may be higher than yours.

06Can I take my Save Our Homes savings to my next home?

Yes, up to $500,000, if you had a homestead exemption on January 1 of one of the three prior years and you set up a new Florida homestead. If the new home costs less, you keep the same percentage of savings. File form DR-501T with your homestead application by March 1.

07How do I look up my property and recent sales in Orange County?

Use the Orange County Property Appraiser's property search, by address or owner name, for values, sale history and exemptions. Recorded deeds and mortgages are in the Orange County Comptroller's Official Records, and permit history for unincorporated Orange County is on Fast Track.

08How accurate are online home value estimates in Windermere?

They're a starting point, not a price. Automated models work from public records and recent sales, so they can't see interior upgrades, the quality of the lake frontage, dock permits or a home's position on a golf course. Check the estimate against truly comparable closed sales.

09How can I get my house appraised for free?

A full appraisal is a paid service from a licensed appraiser, usually ordered by a buyer's lender. Free indicators are easy to find: your Property Appraiser just value and an online estimate. An agent's comparative market analysis adds what those miss, but it isn't an appraisal.

10What adds the most value to a Windermere home?

Location within the community, the lot and view, size, age and condition are the basics. On the Butler Chain, which lake, its size and water quality, and a permitted dock matter. Roof age matters too, because it affects insurance. Exact premiums vary by street and need local comparable sales.

11How is home equity calculated before I sell?

Equity is your realistic sale price minus your mortgage payoff and selling costs: the commission you agree, Florida deed stamps ($0.70 per $100), the owner's title policy if you pay it, any HOA estoppel fee and your share of the year's taxes. Downsizers can also carry up to $500,000 of Save Our Homes savings to the next homestead.

12Will Amendment 3 change my home's value?

Amendment 3 changes taxable value, not market value. Voters approved it on November 3, 2026, with about 62% of the vote, so homesteads get a non-school exemption of $150,000 in 2027, rising to $250,000 in 2028.

Ready for a real number?

Ask Andy for your range.

Send your address with the request form, or call Andy to talk it through. No need to be ready to sell.

Andy Neal, Realtor · The Agency FL · (407) 619-3517

Sources and how we compiled this page Updated November 2026 · 18 sources

How we compiled it

Definitions and rules come from Florida Statutes, the Fannie Mae Selling Guide, federal rules and the Orange County Property Appraiser, each checked in October 2026. Cost figures are worked examples on the statutory rates, not a quote. Andy's valuation is an agent's opinion of value, not an appraisal. Confirm anything you rely on with Andy, the Property Appraiser or your adviser.

  1. Andy Neal, downsizing guide and /sell page, centralfloridalistings.co (October 2026)
  2. Florida Statutes 475.611 and 475.612 (appraisal; comparative market analysis), 2026
  3. Florida Statutes 192.042, 193.011, 193.155 and 196.031 (valuation date, just value, Save Our Homes, homestead), 2026
  4. Florida Statutes 689.261 (property tax disclosure summary), 2026
  5. Florida Statutes 201.02 (documentary stamp tax) and 720.30851 (estoppel certificates), 2026
  6. Rule 69O-186.003, Florida Administrative Code (title insurance premium rates)
  7. Shumaker, DBPR increases association estoppel certificate fees (July 25, 2022)
  8. Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-08 (June 4, 2025) and B4-1.3-09
  9. Quality Control Standards for Automated Valuation Models, final rule, 89 FR 64538 (August 7, 2024; effective October 1, 2025)
  10. Seminole County Property Appraiser, Save Our Homes page (accessed October 2026)
  11. Orange County Property Appraiser, Portability FAQ (Rev. 08/2021)
  12. Florida Statutes 194.011 (Value Adjustment Board petitions); Orange County Value Adjustment Board, vab.occompt.com
  13. Orange County Comptroller, Official Records; Orange County Clerk of Courts, Records page
  14. Orange County Fast Track permit search; Town of Windermere FAQ
  15. Orange County EPD, Boat Docks and Shoreline Alteration permit pages (read October 22, 2026)
  16. Walsh, Milon and Scrogin, Land Economics 87(4), 2011
  17. Citizens Property Insurance, inspections page; IRS Topic 701 (October 12, 2026)
  18. Florida Division of Elections, Ballot No. 3 (Amendment 3, November 3, 2026)

Andy Neal, Realtor, The Agency FL · 4757 The Grove Dr, Suite 124, Windermere, FL 34786 · (407) 619-3517 · Florida Sales Associate, Lic. SL3396613.

The Agency FL (H2 Collective LLC d/b/a The Agency FL), a Florida-licensed real estate brokerage, Lic. CQ1073923. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Andy's home valuation is a comparative market analysis by a licensed real estate sales associate, not an appraisal (F.S. 475.612). Information on this page is for general guidance and was checked in October 2026; it isn't legal, tax or appraisal advice.