Client story · Buying

Helping Orlando City soccer star Dom Dwyer secure his dream home

How strategic pricing and negotiation helped secure a home for less than its appraised value, despite competing buyer interest.

Andy Neal
Written by Andy NealREALTOR® · The Agency FL · Updated
Dom Dwyer and Andy Neal shaking hands at the golf club after Dom's home purchase
Dom Dwyer and Andy Neal enjoying a celebratory round of golf following his successful home purchase.
Client
Dom DwyerFormer Orlando City SC and U.S. Men's National Team player
Andy's role
Buyer's agentRepresentation
Location
Central FloridaPurchase
Result
Below appraisalPurchased below the appraised value
I. The story

Finding the perfect home

When professional soccer player Dom Dwyer, known for his time representing Orlando City SC and the United States Men's National Team, found a home he loved during an open house, he knew he wanted to make it his own.

But there was one challenge: he wasn't the only buyer interested in the property.

Dom reached out to me to help navigate the purchase, and we immediately got to work developing a strategy that would give him the best possible chance of securing the home without unnecessarily overpaying.

II. The challenge

Standing out in a competitive situation

With other buyers showing interest, we knew we needed to act strategically.

It's easy for buyers to become emotionally invested in a property, particularly when they've found somewhere they can genuinely picture themselves living.

However, my role is to ensure my clients make informed decisions, even when competition adds pressure. Rather than simply recommending an aggressive offer, I wanted to establish what the property was actually worth and identify the best way to position Dom's offer.

III. The strategy

Market knowledge meets negotiation

We started by carefully analyzing comparable sales, current market conditions, and the property's overall value.

Armed with that information, we developed a competitive offer strategy designed to appeal to the seller while protecting Dom's financial interests.

Successful real estate negotiations aren't necessarily about offering the most money. They're about understanding the market, recognizing opportunities, and structuring an offer that makes sense for everyone involved.

Andy Neal

With a clear plan in place, we moved forward confidently.

IV. The result

Securing the home below appraised value

Our strategy paid off. Despite the competing interest, we successfully secured the property, and the purchase price came in below the value determined by the independent appraisal.

  1. A home he lovedFound at an open house, with other buyers also interested.
  2. An offer built on valueComparable sales, market conditions and the home's value set the offer.
  3. Bought below appraisalThe home appraised for more than Dom paid.

For Dom, that meant not only getting the home he wanted but also having the reassurance that the property had appraised for more than he paid.

It's exactly the type of outcome I aim to achieve for my clients: combining strong representation with sound financial decision-making.

And what better way to celebrate a successful purchase than with a round of golf? After closing, Dom and I headed out to the golf course to celebrate. It's moments like these that remind me why I enjoy what I do. Real estate is ultimately about relationships, trust, and helping people achieve their goals.

V. More than just finding a home

The same approach for every buyer

Whether I'm working with a professional athlete, someone relocating to Central Florida, or someone purchasing their next luxury home in Windermere, my approach remains the same.

Every purchase deserves careful consideration, detailed market knowledge, and a strategy tailored to the buyer's circumstances.

With 25+ years of real estate experience, I understand that finding the right property is only half the equation. Knowing how to secure it on the right terms is where experience can make all the difference.

Andy Neal
Andy NealREALTOR® · The Agency FL · (407) 619-3517

Looking now? Windermere homes for sale · working with a luxury agent · more about Andy

Talk with Andy

Looking to buy a home in Windermere, Orlando or Central Florida?

Let's put together a strategy that helps you find the right property and negotiate the best possible outcome.

  • You work with Andy directly, from the first showing to closing
  • Offers priced from comparable sales and the home's value
  • Prefer to talk now? Call or text (407) 619-3517

Contact Andy

Name, email or phone, and a line about the home you're looking for.

Lofty's contact form appears here. Prefer to call? (407) 619-3517

Andy Neal, Realtor · The Agency FL · (407) 619-3517

Client story shared with Dom Dwyer's permission. Every purchase is different, and outcomes depend on the home and the market.

Andy Neal, Realtor, The Agency FL · 4757 The Grove Dr, Suite 124, Windermere, FL 34786 · (407) 619-3517 · Florida Sales Associate, Lic. SL3396613.

The Agency FL (H2 Collective LLC d/b/a The Agency FL), a Florida-licensed real estate brokerage, Lic. CQ1073923. Equal Housing Opportunity.

LEAVE A REPLY

Message

Message

Name

Name

Phone*

Phone